Here’s your prognosis…

To read this on my blog site, sign up to be notified of future blogs, and search for past essays on a variety of prostate cancer topics, please click here.

Bill Farwinkle (a fictional patient) and his wife Judy are seated in two chairs in the exam room as I enter, introduce myself, and take a seat in front of the evil, glowing screen that often dominates physician/patient interactions these days. I have read through the urologist’s excellent intake notes as well as those from the radiation oncologist he saw earlier in the week. It is clear that he has been told most, if not all, of the information about his options for treating a Gleason 4+3 cancer found in 6/12 cores, plus the suspicion of a solitary metastasis in his left ilium. So, I start by asking him to tell me about his goals for today’s visit. As soon as it is convenient in the visit, I move the conversation to what he enjoyed about his import business and what he is doing with his retirement, and from there, just let them ask the questions he or Judy are most concerned about. It takes an hour more or less.

These intimate encounters are the raison d’être of my 4 decades of medical practice. Trying desperately to keep up with the molecular biology of how a loss of PTEN or the presence of a mutation in one of the many DNA damage repair genes, never mind any of the multigene panels that could be ordered, hovers over each encounter as I ponder my role in helping an individual navigate a frightening diagnosis or a change in his clinical picture. Before reading any further in this post, I hereby assign you (as is my duty, being a professor after all…) this reading assignment: “Don’t Tell Me When I’m Going to Die” (You need to click on that title and read the short article before continuing).

The promise of “precision medicine” is all the rage currently. For example, in this week’s NEJM there is an article on re-adding the clinical risk parameters to the 21-gene recurrence score now in standard use for certain breast cancer patients. In the accompanying editorial, Hunter and Longo (discussing the complexities imposed by combining clinical and genomic attributes) state, “Within these groups, both physicians and patients will have to face substantial uncertainty, and ‘educated guesses’ informed by multiple sources of evidence as well as by clinical acumen will continue to be necessary even in the age of precision medicine…”

And so, when “Mr. Farwinkle” looks me in the eye at the end of our hour and says, “I suppose you know what I’m going to ask next…” I’m fully prepared to do my best, but in my heart I realize that medicine remains an art. Does he realize that his parents’ longevity, his smoking history, his cholesterol and blood pressure, and his willingness to exercise may play as much a role as the Gleason score or any genomic tests? “How long have I got, doc?” The question hangs there as I ponder how to answer.

We all share the same prognosis: Our time is fleeting, “threescore and ten, I remember well” as Shakespeare quotes in Macbeth. How to factor in the possibility that enzalutamide or abiraterone, a PARP inhibitor, or even an immuno-oncology agent that blocks the PD-1 pathway may affect this truth by a few months or even a year or two is on the one hand hopeful, and on the other, probably irrelevant. If only I could be as eloquent as Paul Kalanithi, the author of “When Breath Becomes Air“. In his original submission to the NY Times, when he was discussing coming to grips with his own cancer diagnosis, he stated, “What patients seek is not scientific knowledge doctors hide, but existential authenticity each must find on her own. Getting too deep into statistics is like trying to quench a thirst with salty water. The angst of facing mortality has no remedy in probability.”

And so I answer the Farwinkles. “I think you are going to be fine. Regardless of your decision as to what therapy we choose, you are likely to have a good outcome initially for several years, and I will be here for you. We can get through this together and we will take great care of you. But just as I have to remind myself, every day is a gift and we should live it like there won’t be unlimited tomorrows.”

Nothing has really changed for him. Or for me. I look forward to getting to know this family better…



Filed under General Prostate Cancer Issues, Prostate cancer therapy

8 responses to “Here’s your prognosis…

  1. Well done, Dr. Glode. This should be required reading for medical oncologists everywhere.

  2. Nancy M.

    Mike, the empathy you’ve shown toward your patients is what made working for you a privilege all those many years ago. Nancy

  3. Bonnie Crawford

    Wow, wish husband’s oncologist had said this to us instead of a cold “about a year, maybe more, maybe less” we were stunned and when we finally caught our breath and asked about options (other than lupron that he added to xtandi) he said “I cannot answer questions when I am putting info in the computer” After telling us “1 year” we thought he should have stopped entering info in computer and talked to us. We never got any information before we left. Wish you were close to us and we we be your patients. I printed out and will give to Dr when we see him in 2 weeks. Hopefully he will answer others like you did.

  4. Bob Lederer

    Mike, As usual you are so absolutely correct about what matters the most to us as patients. It is not about numbers, it is all about caring and compassion along with following the science.
    I feel so fortunate to have found an oncologist in his first decade of practice that does everything you talk about. I was so concerned about changing when my old oncologist retired and this wonderfully compassionate, knowledgeable angel appeared in my life.
    I have forwarded your article and the “required reading” to many who ask how I keep my attitude so positive about having advanced cancer. You have very correctly stated what every patient needs and very few are getting.
    All oncology fellows need to read your article!

  5. Julius

    Good answer to the “how long” question. Thank you for writing and sharing this article.

  6. Kenneth Gue, (RN - BSN - retired Hospice nurse.)

    Very nicely written, Mike. It shows your caring nature that I have known for over 50 years. Continue with your helpful ways.

  7. Pingback: Nex Gen Diagnostics and Treatment | prost8blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s